How to Pick the Best Hay to Feed Goats

Sharing is caring!

You know the old saying, the key to a man is through his stomach? Well, I think it’s even truer with our homesteading animals. The key to healthy and productive livestock is in the food you give them, and this all starts with the basics such as the best hay to feed goats

When I first starting raising goats I thought all hay was alike. Oh, boy, was I ever wrong! There are so many things to know about hay from growing it to cutting or mowing it down. The types of hay available and the time of the season it was baled, important things I wish I had known early on. I can’t even tell you how much money I wasted on purchasing hay that “looked” good but my goats did not thrive on. Hay that came with a hefty price tag but my goats simply refused to eat. 

Yes, it can seem overwhelming at first especially when there are so many aspects to what makes a good quality bale of hay. The trick is to know the process of how hay is grown, what all goes into it and, and finally the best way to store it that will keep its value. If you know those things you will not only provide your goats with a healthy diet but you will save your homestead money as well.  

Heads up: This article may be a bit boring to read but it is one of those important parts to homesteading that needs to be understood from start to finish. So grab yourself a cup of coffee and maybe a pen and paper for a few notes and let’s dive in. 

best hay for goats

How does a goat eat? 

Goats are a lot like deer and tend to forage more than graze. This means they pick and choose the best parts of a pasture. They like to graze often throughout the day going for weeds and leafy plants before turning to grasses. Contrary to the old saying, a goat will eat anything even a tin can, most goats are in fact, picky eaters. This explains why a goat owner’s pasture is hit and miss as to what is eaten down and what is left standing. 

A goat’s rumen is found on the left side of the body. You can more easily remember this by saying Left=Lunch. A large soft and spongy left belly is a sign of a healthy and active rumen. 

SLCG PRO TIP: If your goat has a large belly that is hard to the touch that could be the sign of bloat, a deadly condition in goats where gas becomes trapped in the rumen. Walk your goat to help them remove the excess gas and contact your VET immediately for medical assistance

First, the basics, what exactly is hay?

You may have heard the terms hay and straw used interchangeably in a conversation. Even though they are two different things they are commonly referred to interchangeably. Hay is used for feeding animals because it contains the entire plant; the stem, leaf, and seed head. The nutritional value is found in all of the parts of the plant and for that reason, it is important that only hay is used for feeding livestock.

Straw, on the other hand, is used more in gardening and landscaping because it does not contain the seeds of the plant. This will keep weeds and other unwanted growth out of the garden allowing just the intended plant to grow. 

SLCG PRO TIP: Straw is great to use for goat bedding. Since goats will not eat straw because they prefer hay, you can keep bedding intact. 

There are three different types of hay, Grass, Legume and Cereal Grain. 

  • Grass Hay can be timothy, orchard grass or other types of grass or broom grass.
  • Legume includes alfalfa, clover, or soy. 
  • Cereal Grain includes oat and barley. 

Click here to subscribe


Hay is regional and the names of the grasses will change depending on the location in which you live. Where we live, in Northwestern PA, timothy grass hay is the most commonly found along with orchard grass.

Hay is what we call a cut pasture and as stated above, it includes the stem, leaves, and seed head. This is usually cut fresh and bailed; giving it the most nutritional value. The main purpose of hay is to feed grazing animals and for that reason the timing and care at bailing are crucial. 

Bailing is simply the process of cutting, raking, combining, and stacking the hay into sections. These can range from small squares to large round bales and the prices of the bale will depend, of course, on size but also on the quality. 

round hay bales in a pasture

The process of cutting, raking, drying, and then baling hay is important to know so you better understand which questions to ask before purchasing hay for your goats. 

Hay is first cut (mowed) down and then raked into rows. You may have driven by a pasture of neat rows of cut green grass before. These rows are usually cut in the early morning to allow the dew to help hold the leaves of the hay intact with the stems. The cut hay is then left out to dry usually just that day or a second if needed. It is crucial that excess moisture is removed from the hay to ensure it’s nutritional integrity.

Once the hay has been dried then the baling process can begin. Usually, machines, called balers, will do the baling. They will gather up the hay, bundle it together, tie it with string also known as baling twine and finally toss it into a hay trailer or back onto the grass to be gathered up later. 

Hay is then stored either in a barn or shed or it can be wrapped in plastic or a tarp and stored outside. This will all depend on the weather where you live. The key is to keep the hay dry to again ensure the quality of the hay is left intact preserving its nutritional value for your animals.

goat hay going into the barn

SLCG PRO TIP: Hay must be kept out of the rain to deter spoiling of the hay bale. Moldy hay can not only make your goats sick but even, in some cases, kill so being sure your bales are stored correctly is a crucial part of a healthy herd. 


There are different times hay is cut and this is also important to know. 

First cut hay is the first time the pasture is cut down for baling that season. This is the early spring cutting and tends to be the coarsest of the hay cuttings because of the thicker stems. First cut hay also has the most weeds and the lowest protein of the common cuts. For this reason, the price for first cut hay will be lower than later cuts. 

Second cut hay is next and has a higher protein and nutritional value than first cut and also tends to contain fewer weeds. Second cut hay usually has a softer feel to it and looks greener than first cut. The smell too is more fragrant and actually smells like fresh-cut grass. This cut of hay will be more expensive because of the quality and nutritional levels found in the bales.

It is also a bit hard to come by since the amount of second cut hay all depends on the weather. Hay cannot be cut or mowed in the rain since it needs to be dried prior to baling. A rainy season usually means less hay and that can drive the price of second cut pretty high. 

We prefer to feed second cut to our goats for reasons I will get into later. 

goats eating second cut hay from a hay feeder

Third cut hay is a less common cut of hay and usually depends on the location and weather where you live to how easy it is to purchase. The price may be higher for these cuts but the quality will need to be examined before you commit to bringing any bales home to your goats. Be sure these cuts still include the maturity of growth so you are getting the best quality and protein for your goats. If cut too quickly these bales will not include the full plant, meaning the stem and leaves, which may have your animals missing out on important nutrients. 

SLCG PRO TIP: As with any cut of hay, the amount of dust is also important to consider. Respiratory illness can be common in some animals like horses and goats for example. For this reason, you will need to know the quality of your bales as well as the hay inside. We like to test a bale at home prior to purchasing large amounts for our animals. 

What is the Best Hay to Feed Goats?

Feeding goats can be a bit tricky because they have what is known as a complex digestive system. But don’t let this scare you, I just want you to be aware before you begin so you can better understand how to support your goats in the healthiest way.

Let’s break down a goat’s diet so you can see just why we want to focus on hay from the very beginning. 

a pie grid on what to feed your goats

As the graph above shows, hay takes up half of a goats daily diet. If you do not have access to pasture for your goats, then the grass hay percentage is going to be a bit higher than the graph above.

Since the largest part of a goat’s diet is grassy hay, that is where we are going to put our focus today, in particular, the first and second cuts. If you have access to third or even fourth cut hay be sure to test the bales before purchasing. Check the size of the stem and the quality of the nutritional value of the hay. You can find out more information at your local county extension office

SLCG PRO TIP: Did you know that most goats can live their entire life without any supplemental grain? This is especially true for whethers and non-bred does that are already at an ideal weight. This is why the quality of your goat’s hay is so important. Remember to always make any changes in diet gradually so as not to upset the balance of your goat’s rumen. 

Hay is used as animal fodder, meaning feed for large livestock animals. This will include cattle, horses, goats, llamas, alpacas, and sheep. It is also used for smaller animals such as rabbits. It is important to know the best hay for your specific animals in order to ensure their overall health, growth, and milk production.

Different livestock requires different types of hay and knowing the difference will help you to give better feed to your animals. Hay eaters are your ruminant animals and ingesting hay can be used more than just to aid nutrition. Hay, in goats, for example, will help them to stay warmer in the winter. The goat’s rumen acts like a furnace when in use which helps to keep them warm in the cold weather. 

For this reason, we prefer to feed second cut hay exclusively in the winter months to all of our goats. Since our goats prefer the second cut hay they will eat more that will, in turn, keep their rumens active giving them a bit more protection when those frigid wind chills hit.

Basically, there are three types of goats. Dairy goats, meat goats, and goats strictly for pets or work. Knowing the main purpose of your goats will better help you to choose the best hay and feed. 

Click here to subscribe

The Best Hay for Dairy Goats. 

Hay is particularly important if milk production is the main purpose of your goats. The type of hay will directly affect the amount and quality of milk along with the percentages of butterfat found within. For that reason, Alfalfa hay is a great choice because of it’s higher protein amounts. 


Unfortunately, not all regions have access to alfalfa hay. Luckily there are a few options to help remedy this. 

If you live in a region like we do that does not have a large supply of alfalfa hay then you may want to supplement your goats to help. 

How to Introduce More Protein to Your Dairy Goat’s Diet

Alfalfa Pellets 

Alfalfa pellets are a great option to offer to your goats that will give them a good supply of protein. You can offer them free choice or mix them in with their grain. Since purchasing pellets can be a bit expensive online I suggest checking with your local feed mill for a more affordable option. Be sure to have a secure way to store this option of livestock feed so pests do not have access to it. 


Chaffhaye is premium bagged, Non-GMO Alfalfa. It is our preferred method of feeding alfalfa to our herd. This product is manufactured in Texas but more and more states are carrying it as well. Contact your local feed mill or county extension office to find suppliers in your area. 

Chaffhaye is a moist slightly ground alfalfa hay that is compacted into bags. Once opened you will need to store it in a container that will help to keep the air out. Do not store in sunlight or allow it to get warm or the contents will mold. To know if it is good go by the smell. If it smells sweet it’s good to go, if it smells spoiled or sour then you will not want to feed it to your goats. 

SLCG PRO TIP: Always check your bags of Chaffhaye before purchasing. If the bag is torn that means air has entered the bag and will result in a dried out Chaffhaye. The contents must be moist so the integrity of the bag is important. Do not hesitate to call the supplier and ask for a replacement if a bag is found open or damaged. They should replace it without question. 

Our goats are given Chaffhaye year round and they really love the taste of it. Since feeding Chaffhaye I have found a much healthier and robust herd that is better able to fight off worms on their own which is commonly found in our very wet climates. 

It is always best to promote health every day through diet rather than being forced to treat sick animals. 

For our dairy goats, we prefer to feed second cut hay. This hay is richer and more nutrient-dense that supports the high energy needed for milk production. Second cut is also good to give to any goats that are bred. Again encouraging nutrients to support the energy needed by a bred goat. 

The Best Hay for Meat Goats.

The purpose of a meat goat is to fill the freezer and for that reason, you will want to encourage healthy weight gain in your meat goats. More often than not first cut will work just fine in this area but if you find your goats on the low end of the weight scale you may want to introduce second cut hay. Since most goats prefer the second cut to first cut hay this will encourage them to eat more and help them to establish a better weight. 

More often than not most meat goats will thrive on first cut hay as long as the quality is good and the nutrients are intact. 

The Best Hay for Pet and Working Goats.

Just like with meat goats your goal is simply to make sure your animals are in optimal health. More often than not this can be easily done with first cut hay. Again, if you see your goats are on the lighter side you may want to have a few bales of second cut around. You can either offer second cut exclusively or add it to your first cut to help promote eating. 

goat grazing in a pasture

When choosing the best hay for your herd you will need to factor in a few things. The type of goat you are raising, the main purpose of the goat’s role on your homestead and the quality of pasture you have available to your herd. 

Knowing the different cuts of hay, the process to which they were grown and baled will allow you to make a wiser investment for the best hay for your goats. 







  1. Anonymous says:

    Great article. Interesting read thanks.

  2. JON DERIEL says:

    Hey Tracy, thanks for an informative article on all things hay. I’ve been in love with hay since I was a kid (no pun intended). I tried growing my own food for a time. It was rewarding but also hard work, and as your article illustrates, not simple at all. Nothing is simpler than hopping in my car and picking up dinner at the supermarket. That’s why everybody does it, I suppose. Just saying. : ))

    1. Yes, I agree, Jon…growing food is hard and being at the mercy of the weather is no walk in the park either. However, when things all work out. When the moon is full and those stars aligned and your garden is just bursting with an amazing rainbow of produce, that is when it is all worth it. Every single bit.
      Just saying. 🙂

  3. Denise Ignatowski says:

    Thank you for this information. I’m learning how to raise goats before actually doing so and your article in hay was very informative.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.